A Jewish lesbian with chronic IBS stuck in a time loop finds unexpected love and self-discovery when her childhood crush joins her, leading to a heartwarming romance filled with diverse representation, growth, and the challenges of breaking free from the loop.

Reader Review Summary

"Time and Time Again" is a refreshing and much-needed addition to the young adult romance genre, offering a diverse and inclusive perspective that is both entertaining and thought-provoking. At the heart of the story are Phoebe and Jess, two incredibly well-developed and relatable characters who feel like genuine teenagers navigating the complexities of their identities, relationships, and personal struggles.

One of the book's greatest strengths is its excellent representation. Phoebe, the protagonist, is a fat, Jewish, lesbian teenager who suffers from chronic IBS and anxiety, while Jess, her love interest, is a nonbinary, Jewish, lesbian who is disabled and uses mobility aids. The book does an exceptional job of authentically portraying their experiences and challenges without resorting to stereotypes or preachiness. It normalizes conversations around disability, chronic illness, fatphobia, and the difficulties of navigating the medical system, providing much-needed visibility and understanding for marginalized communities.

The time loop premise is cleverly executed, allowing for both lighthearted and poignant moments. As Phoebe and Jess find themselves stuck in a never-ending August 6th, they embark on a journey of self-discovery, personal growth, and budding romance. Their interactions are filled with warmth, humor, and a genuine connection that makes it easy to root for their relationship. The time loop also serves as a metaphor for the characters' personal struggles, highlighting the importance of breaking free from self-imposed limitations and embracing their authentic selves.

Greenfield's writing is engaging and emotionally resonant, seamlessly blending humor, heartache, and hope. The pacing is excellent, with the narrative moving forward at a steady pace, keeping readers invested in the characters' journeys. The supporting characters, including Phoebe's family and friends, are well-developed and contribute to the richness of the story.

Overall, "Time and Time Again" is a beautifully crafted novel that offers a fresh and inclusive perspective on young adult romance. It tackles important themes of self-acceptance, love, and perseverance while delivering a delightful and heartwarming story. Greenfield's debut is a remarkable achievement, and readers of all ages will undoubtedly find themselves captivated by Phoebe and Jess's unforgettable journey.